A Breakfast Burrito on Anna Maria Island, No Egg Required

At 5350, the breakfast burrito on Anna Maria Island skips the egg by default — pork sausage, potatoes, black beans and pepper jack in a tortilla.

A 5350 team member pulling fresh pastries from the oven at the Pour House
On this page

If you’re hunting for a Southwest breakfast burrito on Anna Maria Island, the one on our breakfast/lunch menu comes with a twist built right into its name: the Southwest egg-free Burrito. It’s $13, built around pork sausage instead of egg, and it’s about as close as you’ll get to a breakfast burrito in Holmes Beach that skips the one ingredient everyone expects to find in it.

What’s Actually In It

Order the Southwest egg-free Burrito and here’s what lands on the table: crumbled pork sausage, diced potatoes, corn, black beans, red pepper and jalapeño pepper, melted together with pepper jack cheese and rolled in a flour tortilla. It comes out with slices of avocado and house pico on the side, which is where most of the fresh, cooling contrast comes from, since nothing inside the tortilla itself is raw or cold. The sausage carries the smoke and the salt, the potatoes give it weight, and the corn, black beans and two peppers are doing the actual “Southwest” work in the name — ingredients that show up a lot more in Tex-Mex and New Mexican cooking than in a Western omelet.

Why Call It Egg-Free, Then Sell You an Egg?

Here’s the part that trips people up: the name says egg-free, and the menu still lets you add an egg patty for $5.50. That’s deliberate, not a contradiction. Most breakfast burritos lean on scrambled egg as the base everything else sits in; this one builds that base out of sausage, potatoes, corn and beans instead, so it holds together and eats like a finished dish without any egg at all. If you grew up on the egg-heavy version and miss it, the add-on gets you there for a few dollars more. If you don’t — maybe you’re after an egg-free breakfast for your own reasons, maybe you just like what sausage and potatoes do on their own — you get the full dish without paying for or waiting on an ingredient you never wanted. One thing it isn’t, egg or no egg: vegetarian. “Egg-free” describes the egg. The pork sausage stays crumbled through the middle of it either way.

The Breakfast Burrito’s Long Road to Anna Maria Island

The breakfast burrito itself has a real paper trail. According to Wikipedia’s entry on the dish, Tia Sophia’s, a diner in Santa Fe, New Mexico, claims the first printed use of the term “breakfast burrito” on a menu, back in 1975 — though rolled tortillas filled with eggs, bacon, potatoes and cheese were already part of New Mexican home cooking before that. McDonald’s didn’t put its own version on the menu until the late 1980s, with Sonic, Hardee’s and Carl’s Jr. following through the ’90s. The Southwest style the name usually points to — chile, beans, potatoes, cheese, sometimes chorizo — is a close cousin of what’s rolled into ours, minus the New Mexican green chile and, on our end, minus the egg too.

Where It Sits on the Breakfast/Lunch Menu

The Southwest egg-free Burrito shares the Eggs and Stuff section with the Jefferson Frittata, which goes the other direction entirely: potatoes, Canadian bacon, peppers and cheese baked right into the eggs instead of around them. Order the frittata if you want the egg front and center. Order the burrito if you’d rather build the plate around sausage, potatoes and peppers and settle the egg question yourself. Both come off the same line, on the same hours — 8am to 2pm, seven days a week, the one stretch of the day that doesn’t change no matter when you walk in.

Come by 5350 Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach and try it either way, egg or no egg, or call 941-251-3681 to see what’s on the line first. It’s on the breakfast and lunch menu every day, 8am to 2pm.

More to Explore at 5350 The Pour House

If you’re starting your morning, don’t miss the best breakfast in Holmes Beach, featuring favorites like avocado toast and fresh baked pastries. Pair your meal with coffee on Anna Maria Island or a smooth espresso drink to complete the experience.

Looking for something later in the day? Enjoy lunch in Holmes Beach or explore dinner on Anna Maria Island, where the menu offers everything from light bites to full meals in a relaxed island setting.